Edge decayed

Weekly reversal: great on 2005–2016, nothing on 2017–2021

· 6 min read

The idea

Short-term reversal: ETFs that fell hardest over the last few days tend to bounce. Rank by 5-day return or 2-day RSI, hold the three or five most oversold, rebalance every 5 or 10 sessions.

What we did

  1. Training sweep (2005–2016): 32 variants, with realistic costs and settled-cash rules.
  2. Fair comparison: against SPY held at the same invested level and at the same volatility, because a strategy that is only invested part of the time looks safer for free.
  3. Pre-registered validation (2017–2021): three variants chosen and written down before the run. 9 runs.

What happened

On training years the best variant had Sharpe 0.689 against 0.404 for SPY, with a 15.6% worst drop against 55.2%. It also beat both matched SPY mixes in 7 of 8 comparison rows. Its deflated Sharpe, though, was 0.893 (bar 0.95), and most of the gain came from lower risk at about 57% invested, not higher return.

Raising per-fund caps made things worse: more trading, more drawdown, lower Sharpe (0.688 down to 0.643 for the best variant).

On validation, no variant passed:

Variant Sharpe (default costs) Yearly return Worst drop SPY buy and hold
A 0.074 0.96% 32.2% Sharpe 0.923, 18.3%
B 0.108 1.52% 32.2% same
C 0.021 0.15% 35.5% same

The full results

Training sweep, 2005–2016. All 32 variants at default costs. Sharpe and returns are as simulated, with idle cash earning nothing, the same basis as the headline numbers above.

Histogram of the Sharpe ratios of all 32 weekly-reversal variants, with SPY buy and hold, the median variant and the best variant marked.
The best variant (0.689) is the right-hand edge of the pack. The median variant scored 0.48, and 22 of 32 scored above SPY buy and hold (0.404); the best variant's deflated Sharpe was 0.893 against a 0.95 bar.
VariantSharpeYearly returnWorst dropTime investedCost drag a year
2-day RSI, top 3, every 10 days, buffer 3, order band 1% Best0.6897.35%15.6%57%0.47%
2-day RSI, top 3, every 10 days, buffer 3, order band 5%0.6827.28%15.3%57%0.47%
2-day RSI, top 3, every 10 days, buffer 0, order band 1%0.6827.21%15.7%56%0.55%
2-day RSI, top 3, every 10 days, buffer 0, order band 5%0.6747.10%15.5%56%0.55%
2-day RSI, top 3, every 5 days, buffer 3, order band 1%0.5545.94%18.9%55%0.96%
2-day RSI, top 3, every 5 days, buffer 3, order band 5%0.5505.89%18.9%55%0.96%
2-day RSI, top 5, every 10 days, buffer 0, order band 1%0.5447.78%28.9%77%0.80%
2-day RSI, top 5, every 10 days, buffer 0, order band 5%0.5447.78%28.7%77%0.80%
All 32 variants, best first
VariantSharpeYearly returnWorst dropTime investedCost drag a year
2-day RSI, top 3, every 10 days, buffer 3, order band 1% Best0.6897.35%15.6%57%0.47%
2-day RSI, top 3, every 10 days, buffer 3, order band 5%0.6827.28%15.3%57%0.47%
2-day RSI, top 3, every 10 days, buffer 0, order band 1%0.6827.21%15.7%56%0.55%
2-day RSI, top 3, every 10 days, buffer 0, order band 5%0.6747.10%15.5%56%0.55%
2-day RSI, top 3, every 5 days, buffer 3, order band 1%0.5545.94%18.9%55%0.96%
2-day RSI, top 3, every 5 days, buffer 3, order band 5%0.5505.89%18.9%55%0.96%
2-day RSI, top 5, every 10 days, buffer 0, order band 1%0.5447.78%28.9%77%0.80%
2-day RSI, top 5, every 10 days, buffer 0, order band 5%0.5447.78%28.7%77%0.80%
2-day RSI, top 5, every 10 days, buffer 3, order band 5%0.5427.97%30.0%81%0.65%
2-day RSI, top 5, every 10 days, buffer 3, order band 1%0.5397.94%30.4%81%0.65%
2-day RSI, top 3, every 5 days, buffer 0, order band 5%0.5265.51%18.2%53%1.15%
2-day RSI, top 3, every 5 days, buffer 0, order band 1%0.5115.39%18.9%53%1.15%
5-day return, top 3, every 5 days, buffer 3, order band 1%0.4946.62%32.9%55%0.93%
5-day return, top 3, every 10 days, buffer 0, order band 1%0.4916.97%35.3%56%0.53%
5-day return, top 3, every 5 days, buffer 3, order band 5%0.4866.44%33.8%55%0.93%
5-day return, top 3, every 10 days, buffer 0, order band 5%0.4816.74%34.8%56%0.53%
5-day return, top 5, every 10 days, buffer 3, order band 5%0.4768.17%43.5%81%0.59%
5-day return, top 5, every 10 days, buffer 3, order band 1%0.4668.07%45.2%82%0.59%
5-day return, top 5, every 10 days, buffer 0, order band 5%0.4587.63%41.4%77%0.74%
5-day return, top 5, every 10 days, buffer 0, order band 1%0.4507.54%42.2%78%0.74%
5-day return, top 3, every 10 days, buffer 3, order band 1%0.4286.13%37.5%57%0.43%
5-day return, top 3, every 10 days, buffer 3, order band 5%0.4095.76%37.7%57%0.43%
5-day return, top 3, every 5 days, buffer 0, order band 1%0.3404.67%31.6%53%1.23%
5-day return, top 3, every 5 days, buffer 0, order band 5%0.3354.58%32.0%53%1.23%
2-day RSI, top 5, every 5 days, buffer 0, order band 1%0.3084.17%18.8%56%1.89%
5-day return, top 5, every 5 days, buffer 3, order band 1%0.3044.59%35.4%64%1.52%
5-day return, top 5, every 5 days, buffer 3, order band 5%0.3044.56%35.5%64%1.52%
2-day RSI, top 5, every 5 days, buffer 0, order band 5%0.3034.11%18.8%56%1.88%
2-day RSI, top 5, every 5 days, buffer 3, order band 5%0.2723.87%24.3%64%1.51%
2-day RSI, top 5, every 5 days, buffer 3, order band 1%0.2693.84%24.2%64%1.52%
5-day return, top 5, every 5 days, buffer 0, order band 1%0.0711.26%35.7%56%1.89%
5-day return, top 5, every 5 days, buffer 0, order band 5%0.0611.13%36.5%56%1.89%
Growth of one dollar and drawdown from peak for the best reversal variant, SPY held on the same days, and fully invested SPY, 2005–2016.
The best variant on the training years. The lower worst drop comes with being invested about 57% of the time, not with a higher return than SPY.

Validation, 2017–2021. The three variants were chosen and written down before this run. Default costs; the last two columns are the same variants at zero costs and at double the usual spread.

2017–2021SharpeYearly returnWorst dropTime investedSharpe, zero costsSharpe, double spread
A: 2-day RSI, top 3, buffer 30.0740.96%32.2%78%0.1050.046
B: 2-day RSI, top 3, buffer 00.1081.52%32.2%76%0.1440.075
C: 2-day RSI, top 5, buffer 00.0210.15%35.5%83%0.060−0.013
SPY, fully invested Reference0.92318.28%33.7%100%——
Growth of one dollar and drawdown from peak for the three validation variants and fully invested SPY, 2017–2021.
All three variants stayed far below fully invested SPY, with worst drops of 32–36% against SPY's 33.7%. Costs did not explain it: at zero costs the best of the three had a Sharpe of 0.144.

Why it failed

Costs were not the cause: with zero costs the best Sharpe in the later years was only 0.144. The bounce we saw in 2005–2016 simply wasn't there in the strong 2017–2021 market. We did not tweak the rules after seeing that, because the pre-registration (the plan we wrote down first) said not to.

Receipts: the training sweep came first; the validation rules were written down and committed before any validation run. 32 + 9 official trials, plus 64 cost-sensitivity and 12 fair-test runs recorded.