Works but not worth it

Turn-of-the-month: invested 12% of the time, earned 4% a year

· 3 min read

The idea

Stocks have historically earned more around the turn of the month. Lakonishok and Smidt, “Are Seasonal Anomalies Real? A Ninety-Year Perspective” (Review of Financial Studies, 1988), used the last trading day of a month through the first three of the next. The rule: take the 200-day trend overlay, but only be invested in those four days.

What happened

Sharpe Yearly return Worst drop Invested
2017–2021, turn-of-month rule 0.75 3.8% 6.7% 12%
2017–2021, plain 200-day rule 0.97 9.0% 13.4% 65%
2022–2023, turn-of-month rule −0.32 2.9% 4.6% 7%
2022–2023, plain 200-day rule −0.05 3.3% 6.1% 39%

The close-to-close premium was real but modest: 0.098% on turn-of-month days against 0.068% on other days in 2017–2021, and 0.046% against 0.021% in 2022–2023.

The official runs

These are the official default-cost results for the pre-registered turn-of-month rule, one of the 15 trials in the literature batch. Sharpe and yearly return credit idle cash at the 3-month T-bill rate, like the figures already on this page. Worst drop is from the simulated book as traded. The SPY rows are reference points, not trials; the same-days row is frictionless, which slightly favours it. The 2005–2016 window was used to form the 200-day average; this rule was not an official pass/fail run there, so it is not in the table.

2017–2021SharpeYearly returnWorst dropTime invested
Turn-of-month rule Pre-registered · Failed its own rule0.753.82%6.7%12%
Plain 200-day overlay0.978.97%13.4%65%
SPY, same invested days Reference1.297.17%4.3%12%
SPY, fully invested Reference0.9218.28%33.7%100%
2022–2023SharpeYearly returnWorst dropTime invested
Turn-of-month rule Pre-registered · Failed its own rule−0.322.87%4.6%7.0%
Plain 200-day overlay−0.053.28%6.1%39%
SPY, same invested days Reference−0.332.74%2.7%7.0%
SPY, fully invested Reference0.124.26%22.1%100%
Growth of one dollar for turn-of-month rule, in 2017–2021 and 2022–2023.
Growth of $1. Turn-of-month rule credits idle cash at the 3-month T-bill rate, the same way as the yearly returns above. The SPY mixes are frictionless. Official windows only; the January 2022 embargo between them is not shown.
Drawdown from peak for turn-of-month rule, in 2017–2021 and 2022–2023.
Drawdown from peak. Turn-of-month rule uses the simulated book as traded. Official windows only.

The rule traded about 15 times its capital a year in 2017–2021 and 9 times in 2022–2023, which cost it about 0.23% and 0.12% a year. Each window is one official run at default costs.

The premium itself is in the daily numbers. This is SPY close to close, on the four turn-of-month days against every other day:

Average daily return, SPY close to closeTurn-of-month daysAll other days
2005–2016 (build window, context only)0.040% (n=575)0.035% (n=2,445)
2017–20210.098% (n=236)0.068% (n=1,003)
2022–20230.046% (n=92)0.021% (n=389)

The gap is positive in all three windows and small in each. The executable book also earns it only on four days a month, which is why it sat in cash 88–93% of the time.

Why it failed

A small premium cannot carry a book that sits in cash 88–93% of the time against a strategy that is invested through most of the market's drift. In 2017–2021 it earned 3.8% a year, with a Sharpe of 0.75, against 9.0% and 0.97 for the plain 200-day rule. The rule also trades about 15 times its capital a year.

Receipts: the rule was pre-registered before the run, as one of 15 official trials in that batch.